Global monkeypox outbreak was ‘waiting to happen’: Waning immunity from smallpox vaccination drives discontinued in the 1970s means only over-50s now have any protection against virus, scientists say
- Britons were routinely offered the smallpox jab until the 1970s, shortly after which the virus was eradicated
- Waning immunity from family of viruses may explain why monkeypox outbreaks becoming more common
- Although not made for monkeypox, Imvanex jab is up to 85% effective because the two viruses are so similar
- Dr Romulus Breban, a researcher at the Pasteur Institute in Paris, said the surge was ‘waiting to happen’
- Professor Neil Mabbott, from the University of Edinburgh, said the under-50s are more susceptible
Eradicating smallpox may have left the world vulnerable to monkeypox, experts have warned amid growing fears about the current outbreak sweeping the world.
Britons were routinely offered smallpox jabs until the 1970s, when the scheme was deemed no longer necessary because the virus had been beaten into submission. Similar programmes were wound down across the world at the same time.
Scientists say the waning immunity from the mammoth inoculation campaigns may help explain why monkeypox outbreaks are becoming more common across the world.
Although not purposefully made for monkeypox, the Imvanex jab — made by Danish-based Bavarian Nordic — is up to 85 per cent effective because the two viruses are so similar. Antivirals and therapies for smallpox also work for monkeypox.
Dr Romulus Breban, a researcher at the Pasteur Institute in Paris, said the current global outbreak was ‘waiting to happen’ because of the world’s ‘almost zero’ immunity level. Nineteen countries have detected cases in the past month, which has sparked alarm because infections usually only occur in west and central Africa.
Professor Neil Mabbott, an immunopathologist from the University of Edinburgh, told MailOnline over-50s are the only group protected against monkeypox. ‘Although the level of immunity will wane in time, smallpox vaccination provides long-lasting protection,’ he said. ‘Some estimates suggest this may last for decades.’
The smallpox vaccine, called Imvanex in the UK and Jynneos in the US, can protect against monkeypox because the viruses causing the illnesses are related
Professor Neil Mabbott (left), chair in immunopathology at the University of Edinburgh, told MailOnline this has left the under-50s are more susceptible to the virus than those aged over 50 who have been jabbed. ‘Although the level of immunity will wane in time, smallpox vaccination provides long lasting protection. Some estimates suggest this may last for decades,’ he said. However, not all experts agree that a drop in immunity is fuelling the monkeypox spread. Professor Paul Hunter (right), an infectious disease expert based at the University of East Anglia, said it was ‘difficult to say’. He pointed to data showing the smallpox vaccine was only fully effective for ‘about five years’
Another 14 monkeypox patients have been spotted in England as the tropical virus continues to sweep the world amid fears it may have mutated to spread easier between humans.
UK Health Security Agency bosses (UKHSA) have now confirmed 71 cases in the unprecedented global outbreak. At least one child has been sickened so far — but no-one has died. Officials have also warned the worst may still be to come.
England has logged 70 cases since the first case was publicised on May 7, while Scotland has recorded one. None have yet been detected in Wales or Northern Ireland.
Officials said a ‘notable proportion’ have occurred among gay and bisexual men but have not provided an exact breakdown. No gender or age details have been shared, either.
Dr Susan Hopkins, the UKHSA’s chief medical adviser, said new monkeypox cases were being spotted ‘promptly’ due to ‘extensive surveillance and contact tracing networks’.
Nineteen countries across the world – mainly in Europe – have already detected the smallpox-like virus, sparking concerns it may have learned to spread easier among humans.
Infections are only detected sporadically outside of west and central Africa, where the virus is endemic in animals. Although, imported outbreaks have always fizzled out naturally after a few cases.
At least 221 monkeypox cases have been confirmed across the world since the first patient was sickened in the UK on May 6, with most infections among gay and bisexual men.
The United Arab Emirates, Czech Republic and Slovenia are the latest countries to log infections.
Pavel Dlouhy, head of Czech Republic’s Society for Infectious Diseases, said: ‘It was only a question of time, we have been expecting this for days.’
The Czech man showed symptoms of the disease after returning from a festival in Antwerp, Belgium in early May. Several monkeypox cases have since been linked with Darklands – a large-scale fetish festival, held from May 5-8.
In Slovenia, a man who developed symptoms after returning from the Canary Islands, has also been confirmed to have monkeypox, according to health authorities. Monkeypox infections have already been linked with the Gran Canarian gay pride festival – attended by up to 80,000 people between May 5-15.
The UAE announced its first monkeypox case in a 29-year-old woman visiting the Gulf country from West Africa.
Meanwhile, England yesterday confirmed 14 more infections, bringing the UK-wide total to 71. Scotland confirmed its first ever case on Monday, while no infections have been spotted in Wales or Northern Ireland.
The UK Health Security Agency is contacting high-risk contacts of confirmed cases and advising them to self-isolate at home for three weeks and avoid contact with children.
They are also being offered the Imvanex vaccine.
This strategy, known as ring vaccination, involves jabbing and monitoring anyone around an infected person to form a buffer of immune people to limit the spread of the disease.
In the UK, high-risk contacts of confirmed cases are being offered the Imvanex vaccine. This strategy, known as ring vaccination, involves jabbing and monitoring anyone around an infected person to form a buffer of immune people to limit the spread of the disease
It has been used in previous monkeypox outbreaks.
The UK’s smallpox vaccination campaign came to an end in 1971, when the disease had been essentially eradicated.
In Britain, babies under 12 months were given the jab, with a booster dose encouraged in school children and adults.
It means adults aged 51 in the UK now are the youngest cohort who could be vaccinated against smallpox and monkeypox.
But the winding down of the campaign, which also kept monkeypox under control, has left unjabbed Britons exposed to the virus.
As the proportion of the UK population with immunity against monkeypox has declined, it has theoretically given the virus room to circulate and be transmitted easier.
Dr Breban told the Guardian: ‘This outbreak was really waiting to happen. Our immunity level is almost zero. People aged 50 and above are likely to be immune but the rest of us not, so we are very, very susceptible.’
In a paper published in the journal Bulletin of the World Health Organization in September 2020, Dr Breban and colleagues warned monkeypox ‘is an emerging infectious disease for which outbreak frequency and expected outbreak size in human populations have steadily increased’.
The team pinpointed the spread of cases beyond west and central Africa as a pattern fuelled by the decline in immunity against orthopox viruses, a family of viruses that also includes smallpox and monkeypox, due to the end of the vaccination scheme.
Professor Mabbott told MailOnline: ‘The monkeypox virus is closely related to smallpox.
‘So smallpox vaccines are very effective against monkeypox.
‘Here too, there is some evidence that smallpox vaccines used decades ago are still effective against monkeypox.
‘Most people under 50 years old are unlikely to have received a smallpox vaccine in the past. This part of the population will not have any vaccine-induced immunity to smallpox, or cross-protection to monkeypox.
‘As a consequence they will be more susceptible to the monkeypox virus than those who have been vaccinated.’
However, not all experts agree that a drop in immunity is fuelling the monkeypox spread.
Professor Paul Hunter, an infectious disease expert based at the University of East Anglia, said it was ‘difficult to say’.
Health chiefs have warned monkeypox, a virus endemic in parts of Africa and is known for its rare and unusual rashes, bumps and lesions, could also spread to some pets and become endemic in Europe. Undated handout file image issued by the UK Health Security Agency of the stages of Monkeypox
Monkeypox outbreak may have been sparked by sex at two raves in Belgium and Spain, WHO expert warns
Sexual transmission at two festivals in Europe may have sparked the world’s escalating monkeypox outbreak, a World Health Organization expert has claimed.
Dr David Heymann, who used to head the WHO’s emergencies department, revealed it was the leading theory behind the origins of the current cluster of cases.
He said: ‘We know monkeypox can spread when there is close contact with the lesions of someone who is infected, and it looks like sexual contact has now amplified that transmission.
‘It’s very possible there was somebody who got infected, developed lesions on the genitals, hands or somewhere else, and then spread it to others when there was sexual or close physical contact.
‘And then there were these international events that seeded the outbreak around the world, into the US and other European countries.’
Despite not naming either festival, health chiefs tasked with containing the virus have already begun tracing cases back to the Gran Canarian gay pride festival – attended by up to 80,000 people between May 5-15.
Meanwhile, three cases in Belgium have been linked with Darklands – a large-scale fetish festival in Antwerp, held from May 5-8. Organisers have since said there is ‘reason to assume’ someone at the event was infected.
Spanish health chiefs have also linked many cases to a single ‘sauna’ in Madrid.
He pointed to data showing the smallpox vaccine was only fully effective for ‘about five years’.
He told MailOnline: ‘I think it would be a push to assume [it gives] significant protection 50 years later. There may still be some modifying effect but I don’t know.’
Scientists do not know the origin of smallpox.
But findings of smallpox-like rashes on Egyptian mummies suggest the virus has existed for at least 3,000 years.
At the peak, it was estimated that 50million cases occurred each year.
The virus, which killed one per cent of those it infected, was last detected in Somalia in 1977 and the World Health Organization declared the virus eradicated in 1980 — the only infectious disease to achieve this distinction.
It comes as scientists warned a vaccination campaign for gay and bisexual men may be needed to tackle the monkeypox outbreak.
A large proportion of cases are among gay and bisexual men. Scientists have suggested the virus was spread through ‘superspreader events’, including festivals and raves, and is now spreading within these communities.
Professor Hunter said: ‘If this outbreak hasn’t peaked within a few weeks, we need to start looking at offering vaccines to gay men, bisexual men and men who have sex with men.
‘It’s common sense to offer this group a preventative option to protect them against monkeypox, while being careful not to stigmatise them.
‘We will never need to vaccinate the entire population, because the risk is so low, but targeted vaccination is sensible.
‘The strategy of offering men who have sex with men a one-off jab is top of the list of the next actions we will need to take.’
Dr Jake Dunning, consultant in infectious diseases at London’s Royal Free Hospital, said vaccination for gay and bisexual men should be considered ‘in principle’.
He said: ‘It requires data first to identify these men as a group with an ongoing, particular risk of acquiring or being exposed to monkeypox.
‘This needs to be done rapidly, after enough time to see how much of a problem monkeypox is in these men, in terms of the number of cases and the impact on their health.
‘But an issue may be available supply of vaccines, if it were to be offered to such a large group of people.’
Health officials are not understood to be considering vaccinating gay and bisexual men yet, but have not ruled out doing so.
The UK had 5,000 doses of smallpox vaccine Imvanex stockpiled before the current outbreak.
Health Secretary Sajid Javid directed officials to buy more than 20,000 additional doses after cases began to rise last week, sources claimed.
Source: Read Full Article
